Feeding Consumerism: The Hidden Fees of Low-priced Meals


I stroll out of the late summer season heat and into the artificial chill of the air-conditioned grocery shop. Despite the fact that the seasons have changed significantly in my neighborhood more than the previous numerous weeks, the shelves of shining vegetables arranged into stage-lit piles appear practically unchanged. Is there drought in California? Have there been floods in the Philippines? Is the altering climate altering the altitude at which apples can be grown in specific regions? The constancy of choice right here betrays no hint of the goings-on in the original locations on which these shelves rely. I study that the city would run out of meals in just a handful of days if the provide chains stopped, but there is no sign of that precarious net of dependency right here. And most of the shop is not occupied by raw create anyway—the majority of its aisles are filled with processed foods that need tiny or no preparation at all. They come out of bags and cans and plastic packets prepared to consume, and their ingredient lists contain unpronounceable products that lend preternatural colour or sweetness or longevity to the contents. Welcome to the contemporary oddity of meals as a customer practical experience.

For millennia, meals has been woven into the fabric of each society on earth as an crucial marker of cultural identity and belonging, a signifies of developing and preserving relationships, and a way for communities to grieve, celebrate, and worship with each other. In lots of components of the globe, gathering, expanding, and preparing meals tends to make up a substantial portion of every day life: folks are intimately involved in the approach of bringing it to the table. For most of us in Western cultures even so, meals has increasingly develop into a commodity or a customer practical experience. We want it affordable, we want wide variety, and we do not want to have to do the dishes. Rapid meals and pre-produced meal solutions abound we are disconnected from the locations our meals comes from, detached from the folks who develop and prepare it, and ignorant about most of its journey to our plates.

When comfort is the highest fantastic, we’re minimizing the time that we commit preparing and consuming meals, but it is unclear what we’re saving time in order to do.

Customer culture has educated us to be passive recipients in virtually each location of our lives to measure price only in monetary terms, and to see revenue as the only aspect limiting our access to practically infinite abundance and wide variety. This narrow point of view threatens our incredibly survival by rendering invisible our interdependent relationships with the folks and locations our meals comes from, the limitations of our atmosphere, and the accurate expenses of our consumption.

Consumerism also has a profound effect on our spiritual lives. Christians are referred to as to steward creation and embody the enjoy of God for our fellow human beings. Approaching meals merely as a commodity hinders our capacity to reside out our mission in the globe by maintaining us ignorant and alienated from the folks and locations we are referred to as to enjoy and care for.

Comfort at a Price

As a smaller-scale farmer, Andy Smith spends a lot of time considering about these problems (complete disclosure: Andy is my husband). His position on the front lines of meals production and land stewardship offers him a special point of view on the industrial meals technique and the customer culture that simultaneously supports and is perpetuated by that technique.

Andy’s passion for agriculture was sparked throughout the years he spent carrying out neighborhood improvement in India, exactly where he initial recognized the hyperlink in between vulnerable human communities and the ecosystems on which they rely. He says that most of his neighbors in the slums had initially come from rural locations, but largely due to the effects of climate transform and unsustainable farming practices, folks had been increasingly becoming forced out of the villages and into densely populated squatter communities exactly where the atmosphere was entirely degraded due to overcrowding and pollution.

Despite the fact that our present culture about meals and the technique that produces it could save time and revenue in the brief-term, Andy points out that comfort basically comes at a higher price in other approaches. When comfort is the highest fantastic, we’re minimizing the time that we commit preparing and consuming meals, but it is unclear what we’re saving time in order to do. As an alternative of spending our leisure hours studying, meaningfully resting, or engaging in relationships with pals and household, we typically rush via the most vital components of life in order to move into additional mindless distraction and busyness.

Consumerism tricks us into believing the worth of our lives can be measured in terms of productivity and revenue, and that happiness is one thing we can realize via getting the ideal solutions and experiences. Ironically, this search for fulfillment via material goods tends to make us much less content material by shaping our desires about a continuous quest for novelty, wide variety, in no way-ending accumulation, and continuous entertainment. In our insatiable quest to consume, we are produced lonelier and much less fulfilled since our busyness distracts us from relationships with other folks, our personal inner life, and practical experience of God. These person impacts have ripple effects in the wider globe, impacting the folks and locations that are linked to the production of our meals.

“Most of human history has been expanding or hunting or procuring meals, and now we commit incredibly, incredibly tiny of our time on interacting with the production of our food–even the consuming of our meals,” Andy says. “When you commit a lot of time in preparing or procuring, then you care about what it is you are applying and exactly where that stuff came from.” But much less time and involvement in bringing meals to the table, he explains, leads to much less emotional and monetary investment in the excellent or the origins of our meals. “Why is comfort the highest fantastic? What is it that we’re saving time to do?”

There has been a cultural shift away from a holistic view of meals as an enjoyable, social practical experience toward a reductionist view of “food as fuel,” he observes. “It’s like, ‘I just will need to get x quantity of calories,’ so you are not considering about, exactly where did this meals come from? How am I consuming it? Whom am I consuming it with? What’s the excellent of this meals?”

Andy cautions that with so significantly distance in between buyers and producers, “it’s incredibly challenging to know who or what has been harmed in the generating of our meals, or if we will be harmed in the consuming of our meals.” He insists that understanding exactly where our meals comes from is important to making sure that we’re participating ethically in the worldwide technique. “Most of us would in no way intentionally harm or cheat or disregard one more human or animal, but when it is all behind a curtain, in lots of approaches we do participate in that harm.”

The Price(s)

What are the harms of the industrial meals technique in which we unwittingly participate? “One is total loss of diversity,” Andy says. When vast plots of land are utilized to develop a single crop, habitats are destroyed since all other species of plants are regarded weeds to be eliminated. Monocropping kills off the insects, birds, and mammals that rely on the weeds, the other animals that rely on these species, and so on.

Chemical pollution from herbicides, fungicides, and fertilizers is one more difficulty. More than time, weeds create resistance to herbicides, so the only way for herbicide application to stay successful is for farmers to steadily raise the amounts they use. That chemical buildup in the crops and the soil is toxic for humans, animals, and other plants. On massive-scale industrial farms, chemical fertilizers typically pollute the nearby water provide by leaching into nearby rivers and lakes.

But maybe the most pressing concern is the way that industrial agriculture treats soil as a neutral medium into which nutrients can be injected, and from which plants can be extracted. More than time, these approaches of synthetically pumping minerals into the soil and taking them back out degrades the soil by destroying its organic microbial complexity, at some point rendering it useless for agriculture altogether. A current UN-backed study reports that a third of the soil on earth has currently been severely degraded, and we’re continuing to shed fertile soil at an alarming price.

Globally, it is projected that sixty years from now, farming will no longer be probable if soil degradation continues at the present price. Andy sees this as an instance of the way in which the logic of consumerism leads to brief-term considering that fails to take into consideration any of the impacts of deriving profit that do not right away show up in a spreadsheet. As a outcome, land is viewed only in terms of its productivity or its profit possible. So when soil in one particular spot is degraded to the point of no longer turning a profit, Andy explains, “new land is opened up, and the approach repeats itself.” Due to the fact the industrial meals technique is only focused on profit, it does not account for environmental expenses. In financial parlance, the depletion of soil is an externalized price.

But harm to the atmosphere is not the only price that is excluded from the sticker cost of our meals. Andy points out that below the present system–one in which agricultural workers are largely excluded from minimum wage legislation, overtime spend, the protections of youngster labor law, and the ideal to organize for much better functioning conditions—“You’re outsourcing a lot of the labour expenses to definitely poorly paid labourers. They’re absorbing a lot of the expenses of production.”

Drawing on information from the National Institute for Farm Worker Well being and the U.S. Division of Labor, Student Action with Farmworkers reports that aside from becoming underpaid, “farmworkers endure from the highest price of toxic chemical injuries and skin issues of any workers in the nation.” The substandard housing supplied to migrant farmworkers by their employers benefits in higher prices of lead poisoning and respiratory illnesses, and the vast majority of farmworkers not only lack wellness insurance coverage but also “risk losing their jobs if they miss work” to seek healthcare consideration.

Recognizing the Physique of Christ

In his letter to the church at Corinth, the apostle Paul problems a stern warning regarding the way the neighborhood is enacting Jesus’ command to try to remember his death and resurrection via breaking bread with each other. At the time, the Corinthian neighborhood is apparently characterized by such substantial inequality and divisions that even at the communion table, every particular person “goes ahead devoid of waiting for anyone else. 1 remains hungry, one more gets drunk” (1 Cor. 11:21). According to Paul, this selfish practice by some of indulging in excess when other folks go hungry is tantamount to “sinning against the physique and blood of the Lord”–their indifference to the hunger and suffering of other folks indicates that these believers are consuming and drinking “without recognizing the physique of the Lord” (1 Cor. 11:27–29).

Reclaiming of the Christian tradition of sharing meals with each other could also develop into a signifies of resisting consumerism by asserting the inherent worth of human beings, the organic globe, and relationships in between us all, apart from any monetary or productive worth.

As opposed to the excluded members of the ancient Corinthian neighborhood, the folks and locations who are suffering as we feast are not even seated with us at the very same table. The hunger that benefits from their exploited labour, or from the approaches that meals production impoverishes their ecosystems and poisons their watersheds in order to feed us, is invisible to us unless we make it our enterprise to know and to care.

Jesus says that the way we treat these who are regarded the least in our society is the way we treat him (Matt. 25:40). What does it imply to recognize Christ’s physique when we collect for meals in the era of globalized, industrial meals?

Neighborhood as Christ-Centered Resistance

For most of human history,” Andy says, “it’s been about a table that which means and relationships and concepts and a sense of belonging and hospitality are all extended.” The very same could be mentioned about the life of Jesus and the early church, as recorded in the Gospels and the rest of the New Testament: they had been continually inviting folks into an practical experience of God’s enjoy and acceptance via shared meals. Hospitality is one particular of the primary approaches in which we practical experience the Kingdom of God and invite other folks into it. It is the way that God’s folks have often constructed communities of inclusion, mutuality, and vulnerability. It is a way to open our residences and our lives to every other, and to God.

As followers of Jesus in the twenty-initial century, our reclaiming of the Christian tradition of sharing meals with each other could also develop into a signifies of resisting consumerism by asserting the inherent worth of human beings, the organic globe, and relationships in between us all, apart from any monetary or productive worth. A Christ-centered strategy to meals would challenge consumerism on 3 levels.

Very first, shared meals can aid us to address the approaches in which consumerism has ordered our priorities, shaped our considering about what is enjoyable, and isolated us from neighborhood. What would it appear like to reframe meals production, cooking, consuming, and even washing dishes as portion of the Christian tradition of radical hospitality, rather than as drudgery or a waste of time? This could imply interrupting habits like unwinding with take-out in front of a screen and rather applying a dwelling-cooked meal to extend care to a neighbor, or to invite a stranger or acquaintance into deeper conversation. That sort of intentional work flies in the face of customer culture’s expectations of low price and comfort, but as Andy points out, “There’s just a specific quantity of function and work that wants to happen for something meaningful to take place, whether or not that is relationships or wholesome meals.”

Second, the selections we make about which meals to contain in these meals can straight challenge consumerism by prioritizing the lives of other folks more than the instant payoffs of comfort, wide variety, or low costs. “In the absence of a direct partnership with farmers, it is crucial to obtain organic and fair trade,” Andy says. But he believes an even much better way to foster wholesome neighborhood about meals is to get to know nearby farmers—visit your nearby farmers’ industry, ask farmers about their approaches and their workers, and obtain from farms that market environmental and human wellbeing. To connect additional straight with farmworkers and help them in their struggle for fair wages and secure functioning circumstances, take into consideration donating or becoming involved with an organization like the Domestic Fair Trade Association.

The roots of consumerism run deep—both in our culture and in our personal hearts and minds. It is a paradigm which shapes our lives so profoundly we are typically unable to even discern its influence. But by drawing on the fertile soil of two thousand years of Christian tradition, we can increasingly understand to recognize the fruit of consumerism, uproot it from our lives, and plant the life-providing seeds of the Kingdom of God in its spot, building a culture in which all of creation could thrive.

Did you delight in this piece of content material from Christ and Pop Culture Magazine? The continuation of this internet site and the insightful cultural evaluation our writers create is only probable via your generous help. Take into account becoming a member for as tiny as $five per month. You will get cost-free stuff every month, complete access to CAPC Magazine (such as all back problems), entrance to our exclusive members group on Facebook — and you will aid us retain the lights on. Join now.


Latest posts