How Identity Politics is Altering the Church


It is no secret that American politics has been overtaken by identity politics—one of the well-liked layers in the social justice agenda. There is a political agenda involved in working with one’s identity group to achieve energy. The conversation has grow to be so intense, that political groups are working with just about every approach doable in order to virtue signal voters and to achieve assistance.

Elizabeth Warren, a white lady from Oklahoma, understands the energy of identity politics as she has not too long ago been attempting to recognize as an American Indian. The “white” category has been polluted by identity politics leaving persons like Elizabeth Warren no other solution other than self-identity techniques. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez mentioned, “It’s critical that we do not ignore the energy of identity due to the fact it is quite highly effective, specifically for girls, specifically for the rage of girls proper now.”

Intersectionality was initially coined in 1989 by Kimberlé Crenshaw, a political activist and radical feminist, in order to aid recognize and help person classes of discrimination or victim groups. By means of intersectionality, the a lot more victim groups a particular person identifies with—the a lot more energy they can acquire. What Kimberlé Crenshaw was in a position to do in the leftist planet of the LGBTQA+ movement by way of intersectionality is now becoming made use of to leverage a social justice movement inside evangelicalism. How is identity politics infiltrating and altering the church?

Hinderance to Discernment

There are numerous scandals and schisms facing the church now. With the rise of the #BlackLivesMatter movement and the #MeToo movement, an intense concentrate upon identity politics inside the evangelical church has impacted the politics of denominations and the conversations inside nearby churches about the nation. It need to be pointed out that the grievance sector is a quite profitable sector and it has now entered evangelical circles. Has this intense concentrate on victim categories and identity politics hindered the church’s potential to discern?

Take the situation of human sexuality and gender identity for instance. The United Methodist Church has currently produced historic choices about their embrace of egalitarianism, but now the debate is centered on human sexuality. Though the outcome is uncertain, most persons think the whole denomination is gearing up for a enormous split.

Inside the Southern Baptist Convention, a new conversation arose in the weeks top up to the 2018 annual meeting in June that was centered upon the denomination’s historic position on complementarianism. Although numerous provided up their opinions, we have to not neglect that just prior to the Convention, Beth Moore wrote a quite critical report that garnered substantially assistance and sympathy. The report was titled, “A Letter to My Brothers” and in her letter she discussed facts of marginalization and discrimination primarily based on her gender. In the weeks top up to the SBC meeting in Dallas, Texas—pastors from all more than the nation had been debating the situation of a lady serving as the president of the biggest evangelical denomination in America. That debate is in motion to this quite day and will probably continue more than the subsequent couple of years.

Having said that, that raises the query about discernment. Has the church lost its potential to discern due to the cloud of identity politics? A big quantity of Southern Baptist pastors would not embrace Beth Moore’s theology, but due to identity politics and the perceived require to empower girls inside evangelical denominations—she receives a pass on her deficient theological positions. Does one’s identity or victim category take priority more than truth?

In a equivalent struggle, each the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) and the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) have been marked by the Revoice Conference controversy of 2018 that has promoted numerous troubling tips and positions concerning exact same-sex attraction and LGBTQA+ Christianity. Though not officially connected to the Revoice Conference, it was held in a PCA church in St. Louis in 2018 and founder, Nate Collins, identifies himself as a Southern Baptist. The Revoice Conference mission states that they exist for the following objective:

Supporting, encouraging, and empowering gay, lesbian, exact same-sex-attracted, and other LGBT Christians so they can flourish whilst observing the historic, Christian doctrine of marriage and sexuality.

The point is clear—homosexuals will use the exact same social justice playbook to achieve recognition and acceptance as other groups who have gone prior to them inside evangelicalism. Now, another ministry has arisen inside evangelical circles with a equivalent objective beneath the name, Living Out. A single of the very first inquiries they tackle on their web page is the query of no matter whether or not a particular person can be gay and Christian? The hyphenated Christian is becoming a lot more and a lot more acceptable inside evangelical circles.

A lot of black Christians are instructing white Christians to be quiet and listen on matters of social justice. Females who match into a victim category are elevated to a platform and provided a higher voice inside the evangelical church. Likewise these who claim to be gay and Christian are suggesting that they have to have a spot at the table to speak also. Has sola Scriptura been replaced by sola identitatem? Has identity politics hindered our potential to physical exercise superior biblical discernment?


Pragmatism is the historic thorn in the church’s side. The wave of the pragmatic movements such as the church development movement have left the evangelical church weak and superficial in numerous methods. When churches, seminaries, and denominations make choices primarily based upon the preferred advantage rather than the truth of God’s Word—it weakens the church. The want to be culturally relevant has brought on numerous churches and denominations to crumble.

Nowadays, identity politics has entered the evangelical church. Some leaders are instructing pastors on how to diversify the colour of their church employees in order to attain across ethnic lines inside their communities. In some situations, they are becoming encouraged to pick lesser certified black leaders more than a lot more certified white leaders in order to attain the aim of diversity amongst church leadership. As soon as once more, such a pragmatic selection is damaging upon the leaders selected and the church as a whole—and the preferred advantage will not outweigh such capitulation. Although numerous conservative evangelicals embrace the sovereignty of God and the sufficiency of Scripture—they give higher priority to pragmatism in how they make choices.

Identity is not only primarily based on ethnic identity, but also gender identity. Why did the United Methodist Church vote to let girls to serve as pastors on Might 4th, 1956 in their Basic Conference? It undoubtedly wasn’t a theological selection, due to the fact the text of Scripture is abundantly clear concerning the workplace of elder (see 1 Tim. three and Titus 1). It was a pragmatic selection in order to appeal to the masses and a want to offset the declining numbers inside their denomination. That move didn’t operate, so now, they’re discussing the situation of homosexual leaders inside their denomination. As soon as a lot more, it is a pragmatic move. When the church bows to pragmatism—the boundaries of Scripture are ignored in order to achieve targets.

Will the Southern Baptist Convention go down the exact same pragmatic road? In numerous methods, the denomination has been traveling the road of pragmatism for years. Having said that, will the denomination that stood courageously upon the inerrancy of Scripture and returned to a commitment to God’s Word repeat disastrous patterns of the previous? Will the identity politics of American culture trigger the enormous ship of the Southern Baptist Convention to drift so far off course that it will be lost in the sea of social justice identity politics? What choices will the SBC make on girls in leadership? Will the SBC continue to embrace intersectionality and a type of evangelical affirmative action in order to move specific non-white ethnic groups by way of seminary applications with the aim of diversity amongst SBC missionaries and pastors serving on the field?

The outcome has however to be determined, but what we have to recognize is that devoid of a firm anchor in God’s Word and devoid of a firm commitment to the sufficiency of Scripture—the SBC and other evangelical denominations will drift far off course and will probably by no means be recovered. Pragmatic choices concerning ethnic diversity, new definitions and boundaries for complementarian positions, and an embrace of the false category of LGBTQA+ Christianity will prove to be a tragic error for the church of Jesus Christ.

What is our Identity?

In the fall of 1620, 102 colonists sailed for the New Planet on a nicely recognized sea vessel recognized as the Mayflower. These Separatist Christians renounced the religious practices of the Church of England and believed that the Church of England was beyond redemption. In 1630, one more group would join the Separatists in the New Planet. This group is recognized as the Puritans. Throughout the “Great Migration” of the 1630s, some 21,000 English settlers came to New England. When these farmers, fishermen, merchants, lawyers, and whole households walked off of the boats—they had 1 prevalent book amongst them—the Geneva Bible.

As they formed communities—the Christians planted churches. The churches discovered their identity in Jesus Christ. The church in America now is becoming driven off course by identity politics. The identity of the church now is becoming attached to the colour of skin and the priority of gender empowerment rather than Jesus Christ.

The church has been by way of an identity crisis prior to. Following the church was established by Christ—followers of Jesus had been called Christians which was initially a term of derision. What the anti-Jesus movement was attempting to do was to recognize the followers of Jesus with his name—specifically the workplace of the Christ of God. Nowadays, the church boldly identifies with Jesus by embracing the title—Christian.

When Paul wrote to the church in Galatia—he pointed to the union that each Jews and Gentiles have in Christ. The bond is Jesus and the church’s identity can not be focused on ethnicity or gender. Paul wrote,  “For as numerous of you as had been baptized into Christ have place on Christ. There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor cost-free, there is no male and female, for you are all 1 in Christ Jesus. And if you are Christ’s, then you are Abraham’s offspring, heirs according to promise” (Gal. three:27-29). Paul mentioned nearly the exact same issue in Colossians three:11. We do not obtain our identity as the “woke church” or the “black church” or the “white church” or the “hipster church.” Alternatively, we obtain our identity in Jesus. We are Christians.

In days of confusion and mission drift, the church have to obtain encouragement in the guarantee of Jesus in Matthew 16:18. Throughout these days of confusing identity politics, we have to courageously reject the require to recognize the church of Jesus with the woke movement of the social justice agenda. We have to boldly stand in opposition to the intersectionality politics in light of the truth that we have a enough Word that is capable of guiding us along the broken roads of our culture (Ps. 119:11). For me and numerous thousands of Christians across America—the Word of God is adequate.

If the church continues to feed the monster of identity politics—it will at some point bite the arm that feeds it. Take into account the direct connection in between identity politics and the freedom of speech restrictions and hate crime legislation that are promptly approaching the church in our day. These products are not isolated nor are they disconnected from the overarching social justice agenda. Nowadays the church is becoming increasingly woke, but in reality it desires to be awakened to the truth of the gospel alone.



Latest posts