How do you separate sheep from goats? And why would Jesus? – Faith Presbyterian Church


A buddy of mine had a dream.  He dreamed a parable.

In the dream, he was a goat.  His name was Billy.

In the dream, my buddy noticed that the goats and the sheep looked fairly a lot the exact same and have been all herded with each other.  He figured he will have to be in the Mediterranean or the Middle East.  It is not like American or European livestock, exactly where sheep are fluffy, and round and goats are hairy and scrawny.  No, he was someplace that sheep and goats appear fairly alike.

In the dream even though, Billy could really feel that goats are unique.  Billy looked at the sheep and could inform that they have been stupid.  Goats, Billy believed, are intelligent.  Sheep get lost and have to be located.  Goats are organic leaders.  Even sheep will stick to them.

So, in the dream, Billy was feeling really superior about becoming a goat.  He practiced top some sheep astray, away from the grass they have been seeking for.  Some of the lambs, separated from the ewes, produced a wonderful racket.  That led to a confrontation among Billy and 1 of the rams.  Billy’s horns have been larger and extra threatening so the ram backed down.

Billy was having a small bored with the complete herd issue, so he gathered up his household.  He was shocked to recognize he had a household – but there they have been.

Billy took Nanny and their children and headed up into the mountains.  They climbed more than substantial rocks and scampered along steep cliffs till they had gained a lot of altitude.  Billy knew that he and his household had in no way been this higher just before.

Billy and his household stood at the summit.  They looked out and they could see into the future.  There, on a cloud, they a substantial herd of human beings.  All the persons looked a lot the exact same to Billy.  Except for 1.  There was 1 particular person in shining white clothes.  He sat on a glorious chair just before all the other individuals. Angels stirred the air about him.

All of the persons who looked really a lot the exact same have been milling about till the shining 1 raised his arms.   The persons became quiet, so quiet that Billy and his household could hear what the shining 1 was saying. He was separating the persons into two distinctive herds, 1 on his proper and 1 on his left.

As he moved some persons to his proper he mentioned to them:
Come and reside with me forever for when my mother couldn’t care for me you took me in and gave me a bed and boundaries even even though I wasn’t a cute small newborn but a surly teenager and I failed to do my chores and ran up your telephone bill.

To other individuals he mentioned:
Come into my family’s house mainly because when I was hungry and the only true meals my kids got have been when they went to college, you stocked the shelves of the meals pantry and – with some dignity – I could pick what I wanted and cook for my household.

The shining man mentioned to some:
You will inherit with me mainly because when I was a prisoner to my addictions, you did not turn your back on me, you kept speaking to me, expecting extra of me, delivering me with therapy, business, and drugs even when it looked like I would in no way be cost-free.

As he sorted out the persons he mentioned to some other individuals:
Come and reside with all my brothers and sisters, mainly because when I was sick and in the hospital and in the nursing house and in hospice you came and visited me, even even though you have been uncomfortable and didn’t know what to say and occasionally I was angry and threw factors and in the finish I could only let you hold my hand.

The persons gathered on the proper looked into the face of the glorious 1 and admitted:
We in no way saw you.

He mentioned:
I know you didn’t see me.  But every single of these persons – who seemed so unimportant to other individuals – are element of my household and critical to me.

Then he turned to the persons who have been left.  To Billy, this group looked just the exact same as the 1st group, except now they looked really sad.

As angel wings thrummed about him, the shining 1 mentioned these on his left:
When I was hungry and homeless and enable for my household you mentioned you have been worried that your location of worship would get banged up and dirty, so you would not participate in Household Guarantee and we spent yet another 3 months living in our auto.

When I was thirsty, mainly because the water in my taps was poison, you mentioned I ought to move to a improved place, even even though I lived exactly where I could buy a house, soon after you had redlined the city, to segregate persons like me.

When I was vulnerable and at danger and felt naked just before persons with extra sources, you mentioned I ought to pull myself up by my bootstraps, get a second job and study how to price range – even even though I nevertheless couldn’t spend rent for a rundown 1-bedroom location.

When I produced a error, the exact same error you have produced, you told me to spend a fine, and when I couldn’t spend it, you added to my debt, and when I couldn’t spend my debt, you place in me prison and persons produced a profit out of my imprisonment and if you ever believed of me at all you mentioned, “People ought to obey the laws and this wouldn’t take place to them.”

The shining 1 looked more than all of the persons on his left and mentioned:
You did not care for me when I required you.

The persons gathered on his left looked proper into the face of the glorious 1 and admitted:
We in no way saw you. If we had recognized it was you, we would have accomplished some thing.

The shining 1 mentioned:
You let other individuals reside in hellish situations and now you will bear eternal consequences. You turned away my household so there is no location for you in my family’s property. These who lived with the values of my household have been often living a righteous life.  A righteous, caring, compassionate life is eternal.

Just then, clouds blew up the mountain and blocked Billy’s view.  He and the household stood there seeking into the distance for a although. Even the children have been quiet.

Then Nanny mentioned, “If I have been a human becoming, I would pretend to see that shining 1 in absolutely everyone.  I’d enable persons like I was assisting him.  That way, I’d finish up having to go with the shining man into his father’s house.”

But Billy’s oldest kid spoke up. She bleated: “No.  No, I do not feel they can strategy it like that. I feel some of these persons have been just content when they have been assisting other individuals and that tends to make them content forever.”  And then she bounded away just before either Nanny or Billy could say yet another word.

Billy followed his household down the mountain, lagging behind.  He was nevertheless a goat, but he was pondering human thoughts – the way you can in a dream.  He was pondering about what he had observed and what his goat household had mentioned.

He didn’t notice that he had fallen far behind absolutely everyone else till he heard a bleating.  Billy stopped and looked to exactly where the noise was coming from. He could see down beneath that there was a goat – no, a sheep – caught in a thicket.

It was a ram, all tangled up in vines and brambles.   Billy remembered how superior he had felt to all the sheep and how sheep have been often having themselves into predicaments they couldn’t get themselves out of.   Then he believed about how these persons in the future all looked the exact same and how it could be challenging to inform sheep and goats apart.

The ram bleated once more and Billy went down to him in the ravine and made use of his powerful horns tear away at the thicket.

When the ram was cost-free and got his footing, he looked proper into Billy’s face, and then the two of them produced their way back down the mountain with each other.

When they produced it back to the herd, Billy looked about.  He felt a type of joy to see absolutely everyone with each other. The sheep and the goats all seeking the exact same.

Billy the goat was all of a sudden really tired.  He laid down, closed his eyes and believed about all he had observed and heard.  As he nodded off, he felt a beautiful light in his tired, torn up physique.  It was as if he was filled with the light of the shining 1, seated on that glorious chair.

Then my buddy heard a voice kid calling him.  And it wasn’t calling him Billy.  He woke as his kid climbed up on the bed and looked proper into his face.  He could nevertheless really feel the light of his dream and it felt so excellent. My buddy wrapped his arms about his son.  He told him:
This is a new day. Currently, I am waking up in eternal life.


This sermon is totally a riff on a sermon by William (aka Billy) Loader, referred to as “The Enlightenment of a Goat”.  Murdoch is a professor emeritus of Murdoch University and has written extensively on challenges of sexuality in the New Testament.  He preached  to the worshipping neighborhood at Bishop’s College, Calcutta, India, in November, 1999, through four-week keep.



Latest posts