Much more than Writers: Critique of Fay Weldon’s ‘Why will no a single publish my novel?’


I’ve located a tiny gem in Fay Weldon’s modest book ‘Why Will No a single Publish my Novel? – a handbook for the rejected writer’. Her title captures the despair extremely properly, I believe.

Weldon is an uber-writer of novels, screenplays, brief stories, non fiction and children’s books. So she should really know what she’s speaking about.

Though my existing WIP has been accepted for publication, it is a memoir and not a novel, and I’ve had a lengthy history of rejected novels and the resultant sobbing into my coffee. So it piqued my interest when I spotted Weldon’s book in the shop.

Also, as I flicked by way of the pages, I could see that the tips Weldon provides is equally as relevant to me – two-thirds by way of a memoir’s 1st complete draft with a deadline this August – as to any individual writing a novel.

Thirdly, the book is purple, and I like purple.

I am not saying Weldon is appropriate about all the things. We know these items can be subjective. But, regardless, I am passing on – mostly in my personal words – ten causes she provides about why a novel may well be rejected.

1. You have written your novel with the logical, rational, red-pencil, sensible side of your brain and not with the inventive, revolutionary, dreamy, fuzzy side. Therefore, it is dull. Let your self go. 

two. You have refused to acknowledge that even novels will have your private stamp on them – your struggles, your sins, your failings. So you have attempted to hold back, or stand aside, and as a outcome, your novel appears significantly less human, significantly less relatable. Your characters do not appear like genuine, flawed, complicated persons.  Appear for what you have in popular with other humans rather than resisting it, and create about that.

three. You did not keep on track in the story mainly because you weren’t certain what the track was. You have to have a mission statement from the start out that expresses what you are attempting to say. What do you want to inform the globe? Examples involve ‘True like constantly finds a way’ or ‘Children can ruin their parents’ lives’ or ‘Bitterness will hurt you far more than it hurts the offender.’ As soon as you have your mission statement, all the things in the book has to serve that, and not deviate from it: settings, characters, events and structure. Hold referring to it, like a benchmark.

four. You have not attempted to hold the mission statement easy – do not more than-complicate with sub-plots that could probably kind an additional book. Hold a thing for subsequent time.

five. (Controversial, this a single.) You did not construct a plot ahead of you started, so you wandered about and located your self bogged down in the middle, questioning what should really take place subsequent. And it shows. Program 1st. Map out the journey.  

six. You forgot that a lot of readers skim-study and miss facts. So you have to be extremely clear. If a person starts to speak, exactly where are they? Who are they with? What time of day is it? Inform your reader stuff. Never leave them struggling. There is a distinction among ‘suspense’ and ‘puzzle’.

7. You did not make your goodies and baddies quick to spot. Readers like to know, and determine. Yours have been confused about who was who.

eight. You denied your reader the restoration of order. Their genuine lives are usually chaotic and appear disorderly. They use novels to reassure themselves that all will be properly. Give them that. This does not imply, necessarily, delivering pleased endings, but undoubtedly make certain that the unjust get justice and that any individual who deserves a break receives a single.

9. You did not give all the characters Desires. Every person has wants, and it is these wants that make them human and identifiable-with. Even minor characters have wants and that will quit them from getting cardboard characters. For instance, make the postman in your story want for new boots. Also, make your characters come alive by displaying techniques in which they deviate from the norm. For instance, give them striking red hair even although they are shy, or lengthy painted nails even although the rest of them is shabby. Mention that they are particularly tall, or specifically loud when speaking. Make them distinctive.

10. Also a lot of of your sentences did absolutely nothing. ‘A sentence should really either ‘set the scene, advance the action or inform us far more about a character.’ If your sentences, specifically these in dialogue, do not do any of this, they could be superfluous. So, in narrative and dialogue, reduce straight to the speedy. Get into the heart of the scene. Never have hellos or goodbyes unless they matter.

For me, Numbers two and three are proving important. I can currently see a distinction in my writing.

Cheers, Fay.

Fran Hill is a writer and teacher living in Warwickshire. You can study far more about Fran like specifics of her 1st book ‘Being Miss’ from her website right here  Her new book ‘Miss, What Does Incomprehensible Imply?’ is to be published by SPCK in 2020. She does not advise sobbing into coffee unless you like your coffee on the weak side.


Latest posts